EDIT: Figured it out. There was a small bubble that popped up above the transfer screen that said I had an incomplete transaction, in different words. Clicking that allowed me to finish signing the transaction and the AVAX showed up on C chain.
Last night I was transferring my AVAX from P chain to C chain. However before I could sign the second transaction my baby woke up and I went to help him back to sleep. I fell asleep too, and when I woke up in the morning, there was no AVAX on either chain. How do I sign the second transaction now? There is no option to complete the transfer. Someone help please.